Melvin, Macha and Peterson Hold Steady in BCB Tracking Poll

Published June 3, 2010 at 4:00 a.m.

243 readers responded to this week's poll. Here are the notable results:

• There were no notable changes in Doug Melvin, Ken Macha and Rick Peterson's approval ratings. The three were at 44%, 12% and 10% last week and received 43, 15 and 10% approval this week, respectively.
• 67% of voters think the Brewers are making the right decision by starting Chris Capuano tomorrow.
• 47% of voters think the Brewers should trade Corey Hart.

Follow the jump for the full results!

Chris Capuano will start Thursday's game for the Brewers, replacing Manny Parra in the rotation. Is this the right move?

Response	Votes	%
Yes	168	67%
No, he should have replaced Randy Wolf	2	1%
No, he should have replaced Dave Bush	16	6%
No, he should have replaced Chris Narveson	36	14%
No, he should have been left in the bullpen	16	6%
No, he should have been left in AAA	5	2%

 

The Brewers intend to pair Jonathan Lucroy with Randy Wolf and possibly one other starter. Is this the right amount of playing time for Lucroy?

Response	Votes	%
No, it's too much	8	3%
Yes, it's just right.	185	74%
No, it's not enough	50	20%

 

Corey Hart is eligible for arbitration one more time in 2011 before becoming a free agent. What should the Brewers do with him?

Response	Votes	%
Attempt to sign him to a long term deal.	29	12%
Keep him for now, but don't offer a long term deal.	97	39%
Attempt to trade him.	117	47%

 

Yovani Gallardo became the third major league pitcher to throw at least 120 pitches in three games this season with his outing on Friday. Are you worried about his workload?

Response	Votes	%
Yes	96	38%
No	119	48%
Undecided	28	11%

 

Do you approve of the job Doug Melvin is doing as General Manager of the Brewers?

Response	Votes	%	Prev	Diff
Yes	107	43%	44%	-1%
No	75	30%	30%	n/c
Undecided	61	24%	26%	-2%

 

Do you approve of the job Ken Macha is doing as Manager of the Brewers?

Response	Votes	%	Prev	Diff
Yes	38	15%	12%	+3%
No	165	66%	70%	-4%
Undecided	61	16%	18%	-2%

 

Do you approve of the job Rick Peterson is doing as Pitching Coach of the Brewers?

Response	Votes	%	Prev	Diff
Yes	25	10%	10%	n/c
No	132	53%	57%	-4%
Undecided	86	34%	34%	n/c

 

Do you approve of the decision to sign Randy Wolf to a three year deal?

Response	Votes	%	Prev*	Diff
Yes	186	74%	80%	-6%
No	32	13%	12%	+1%
Undecided	25	10%	8%	+2%

 

Do you approve of the decision to sign Doug Davis to a one year deal?

Response	Votes	%	Prev*	Diff
Yes	146	58%	58%	n/c
No	75	30%	30%	n/c
Undecided	22	9%	12%	-3%

* - The questions about Wolf and Davis were not asked last week, so "Prev" in this case refers to the results from the poll two weeks ago.

Back | Read more at brewcrewball